City Council Meeting – November 9, 2026

Introduction:

Links to the video recording and the council packet are at the bottom of this post. Please note any errors or omissions in the comments. Anything in brackets was inserted by Clarkston Sunshine.

Agenda Item #1, Call to Order (video time mark 0:00:00):

Sue Wylie said it’s 7:00. I’m calling the meeting to order.

Agenda Item #2, Pledge of Allegiance (video time mark 0:00:03):

Wylie said if everybody would please rise, we will say the Pledge of Allegiance.

(Pledge said.)

Wylie said thank you.

Agenda Item #3, Roll Call (video time mark 0:00:23):

(To Jonathan Smith, city manager), Wylie said if you would take the roll call, please. Smith said I’ll let Angie [Guillen, clerk] do it. Wylie said oh, I’m sorry. (To Guillen), Wylie said if you would take the roll call.

Sue Wylie, Laura Rodgers, Amanda Forte, and Erica Jones were present.

Gary Casey, Al Avery, and Ted Quisenberry were absent.

Agenda Item #4, Approval of Agenda – Motion (video time mark 0:00:46):

Wylie said our fourth item on the agenda is approval of the agenda. I’ll need a motion and then a second to approve the agenda.

Motion by Jones; second Rodgers.

Wylie said discussions or comments from anybody on council?

No comments.

Wylie said from anybody in the public?

No comments.

The motion to approve the agenda passed by unanimous voice vote.

Wylie said the agenda is approved.

Agenda Item #5, Public Comments (video time mark 0:01:12):

[Though public comments can sometimes irritate the city council, there is value to both the council and the public in hearing them. While they can’t eliminate public comments entirely without violating the Open Meetings Act, your city council has occasionally decided not to acknowledge public comments during a city council meeting unless the person submitting the comments also appears at the meeting (in-person or electronically) to personally read them. In the past, members of the public have been cut off for exceeding the city council’s arbitrary three-minute time limit (it’s arbitrary because no time limits are required by the Open Meetings Act).

If your public comments were submitted to the council but not read, or if you tried to make public comments but your comments were cut short, please email them to clarkstonsunshine@gmail.com and I will include them in my informal meeting summaries either under public comments or under the specific agenda item that you want to speak to.]

Wylie said Item #5 is public comments.

(Wylie read the rules for public comments.)

Wylie said would anybody like to make a public comment? No, OK. Just a wave. Anybody?

Forte said I’ll just say something. Wylie said go ahead.

Forte said [to city manager Smith] thank you for dropping off my packet. It was super helpful. And I was able to look it over over the weekend. So, thank you. Smith said great.

Wylie said anybody else have a public comment?

No comments.

Wylie said thank you.

Agenda Item #6 – FYI: (video time mark 0:01:56):

Wylie said Item #6 is FYI. We have one FYI from Laura Rodgers.

Rodgers said just a reminder that the Christmas market is on December 12th from 4:00 to 8:00 p.m. Wylie said no, I’m sorry. That’s personal. Rodgers said oh, OK. Wylie said that date just registered with me. Sorry. Rodgers said we have had great community support. And I think everything is starting to fall in line. So yeah, just wanted to make sure everybody knew about it. Smith said I was planning on putting that in the next packet. Rodgers said oh, I won’t be here at the next meeting. So that’s why I just wanted to. But that would be great if you could bring it up again. Wylie said thank you.

Agenda Item #7 – City Manager’s Report (video time mark 0:02:36):

    • 11-09-2026 City Manager’s Report (page 3/39 of the council packet)

Wylie said Item #7 is city manager’s report, which is included in the packet. (To Smith), Wylie said did you have anything to add to it?

Smith said just to reemphasize my thanks to the election team for a job well done. It’s more than just one day. It’s the nine days of early voting. It’s absentee voting. It’s really an exhausting week. And I was just on the outside kind of looking in. Guillen and Evelyn [Bihl, administrative assistant/treasurer assistant/deputy clerk] did all the heavy lifting. And I want to thank them for all their hard work. And the rest of the team here is noted. But it was a good group effort. And all went very, very smoothly.

Wylie said yes, thank you. I know it’s a little more, not only being a diverse group, but there are some names that I did not recognize from previous elections. Smith said yes.

(To Smith) Wylie said anything else on? Smith, anything else on? Smith said no, I’ll defer the other items for now.

Wylie said OK, anybody on council have questions or comments on city manager’s report?

No comments.

Wylie said anything from the public?

Wylie recognized Richard Bisio for a comment.

Bisio said I have just a couple of questions. The report talks about a downtown sidewalk and driveway apron renovation review. And it involves the engineering for Fleis & Vandenbrink. I wanted to know whether there is a cost to the city for that. Do we have a contract with them? Is this – Smith said that is correct – (continuing), Bisio said we’re starting to spend money from the grant on this? Smith said we haven’t yet. But that is forthcoming. I expect to have, maybe at the next council meeting, an agreement for partnering and contracting with Fleis & Vandenbrink to do that work, engineering work. Bisio said OK, is that a cost that is in excess of the grant money plus the city’s matched cash? Smith said no, it’s part of that. All contained within that. Bisio said so, what they’re doing with this walk-through now is going to be rolled into that contract. Smith said that’s right. Bisio said OK.

Wylie said anybody else on city manager’s report?

No comments.

Wylie said thank you.

Agenda Item #8 – Oakland County Sheriff’s Report for October (Lt. Buchmann to attend) (video time mark 0:05:03):

    • Lieutenant Jeff Buchmann, Oakland County Sheriff Department Cumulative Report Through October 2026 (page 4/39 of the council packet)

Wylie said Item #8 is Oakland County Sheriff’s report for October 11. Is it Buckmann? Lieutenant Buchmann said yes. Wylie said Lieutenant Buchmann is here. Thank you. Yeah, you can stand at your seat or come up there. Lieutenant Buchmann said (unintelligible). Wylie said so, then you have a little platform to put your paperwork. Thank you, and thank you for attending. Lieutenant Buchmann said oh, thank you for having me. I didn’t have, so there is a report that, I just have the crime stats from last month. Wylie said OK. Lieutenant Buchmann said OK, OK. I didn’t know if there were some specific questions that needed that. I got a text from Smith that there was going to be some questions, which is fine. I just didn’t know if that’s still on the table.

Smith said I do have the questions that, in his absence, Quisenberry submitted to me. So, I have those. But if you want to go through the crime report, then I can speak on Quisenberry’s behalf and go through the four primary questions he had. Lieutenant Buchmann said OK.

Lieutenant Buchmann said well, first of all, I’d like to introduce myself, because I’ve never been to the village. I’m Jeff Buchmann. I’m the lieutenant of the Substation Independence Township, which covers, obviously, the Clarkston area. I was born and raised in Clarkston. And I spent my whole life here. I grew up at Mustang, Pauling, and Bronco, down in that area. I used to spend a lot of times riding my bike through downtown. And I was that kid that rode over the bridge in the middle of town and made all that noise. Yes, that was me. So, I’ve lived here, except for the four years I went to college and a couple of years that I lived in Pontiac, when I worked for the Pontiac police. Other than that, I’ve always lived here in Clarkston. I raised my family here. My boys went to school here. So, I love this community. I love this town. And I just wanted to introduce myself.

Lieutenant Buchmann said as far as crime stats, it’s been pretty quiet here in the village. In October, we didn’t have any felony or misdemeanor arrests. We didn’t have any violent crime reports or any property crime reports. We had three citations issued, which seemed a little low to me when I looked at it. And for the year, we have had zero violent crimes in the village reported. And (to an unidentified man in the audience), Lieutenant Buchmann said oh, you’re OK. I just turned around. I’m trying to use. The unidentified man said I’m sorry. Lieutenant Buchmann said and I didn’t know I was going to be on the news tonight. And for the year, there’s only been five misdemeanor arrests in the city. Now, that in the village, that can be misleading. If somebody stops somebody, if one of the guys stops somebody and they don’t have a driver’s license, whether they live in the community or not, if they have a suspended license, they write them a ticket, that’s considered a misdemeanor arrest. So, I could get those numbers of every single arrest that we had because they’re so, they’re so low. But I didn’t bring those today. So, I can get those at any date. For the village, last month in October, we had 39 calls for service. And to year to date, we’ve had 534.

Wylie said OK. Anybody on council have questions about the report that’s in our packet? Lieutenant Buchmann said is this what you, you guys get this report? Wylie said yes. Smith said yeah.

Jones said how are you guys doing on staffing? Lieutenant Buchmann said we’re doing good. We do have some vacancies in the, in the substation. Every substation in the county has vacancies. But we supplement them on overtime. There is no cost to the township or the village. So, we are always staffed (unintelligible) on the road.

Wylie said I’m sorry. Generally, how many deputies are assigned to a shift? Lieutenant Buchmann said between five and three. Three and five. Three is the minimum that we would ever have. Wylie said OK. Lieutenant Buchmann said I think when I was at the substation this afternoon, there was four on. It just depends on if training and vacations, and if somebody calls in sick. Wylie said OK.

This is what Smith. Yeah. (To Smith), said do you want to go ahead. Smith said so that’s a good segue into the first question. That really answers the first question.

Smith said so, the next one was periodic inspections of alcohol retailers. So, is there a process of doing that periodically? Lieutenant Buchmann said there is a process. And I will, we have not been doing them that frequently. But if there is an issue or a problem in the village with any of the establishments, we would do it. And if that’s something that you’re asking us to do in the Sheriff’s Department, we would, by all means, we would do that. We have not had any complaints forwarded to us that any of the, any of the establishments downtown have had, aren’t abiding by the proper liquor license, or that they’re not licensed, or that there is after hours selling, or anything like that. We have not had any type of complaints. So, but if that’s something that we wish, you know, we can definitely do that. But it’s not a problem. Wylie said OK. Lieutenant Buchmann said it’s not a strenuous process. Smith said Quisenberry’s brought this up a couple times. So, I think on his behalf, he would like us to investigate that possibility of doing some – Lieutenant Buchmann said OK – (continuing), Smith said alcohol checks.

Smith said thirdly was a question about police including patrols through the city. So, when you drive through the city on the way to a township call, does that count as a police call in the city on these statistics? I don’t think it does. Lieutenant Buchmann said no, it does not. Smith said OK. We didn’t think it did. Lieutenant Buchmann said now, if somebody, a resident or somebody on the board, were to call and say, we have someone running a stop sign at downtown, or Washington, and wherever, and we were to go sit and watch that, yes, they probably would pull a call number or case numbers. Smith said sure. Lieutenant Buchmann said we would. But generally, when the guys are driving through, they do not. Smith said OK.

Smith said and the last question he had, and I’m kind of summarizing, I’m assuming he had other ones, he’ll let you know. The question has come up a few times. Would it be possible for the city, on an extra payment per hour basis, to contract with the Oakland County Sheriff for special details, if we would like? If we would like to say that we’ve noticed an increased speeding on Holcomb, that we could pay for an officer to monitor that on a Tuesday night, or whatever, is that something that you have the manpower to provide? Lieutenant Buchmann said yes. That’s something that we could, that we could facilitate. We also, if we were to get a call to either myself or one of the supervisors down at the substation, and wanted extra patrols, that would be free for, that would be free service. But that comes with, if we’re busy elsewhere, we can’t. But yes, if you had an issue, and you needed a deputy to dedicate himself to that specific area or issue, yes. Yes, we can 100% do that. Smith said OK. Lieutenant Buchmann said that would just entail either calling myself or calling Sergeant Bowie [no spelling provided] down at the substation. We can get that going, for sure. Smith said we have had some specific complaints – Lieutenant Buchmann said OK – (continuing), Smith said mainly about speeders, on Main Street and Holcomb. Those are the two main roads. So as those kind of complaints come in, I can work with Sergeant Bowie to see what we can do to address that. All right.

(To Rodgers), Wylie said go ahead, you have something?

Rodgers said when you said that there are three to five deputies on per shift, is that just for Independence Township/Clarkston, or is that for all of Oakland County? Lieutenant Buchmann said well, for Independence Township and Clarkston. Rodgers said OK. Lieutenant Buchmann said yeah. No, each substation has a minimum manpower, depending on the population of the township. So, it’s more size than it is population, I guess I should say.

Wylie recognized Forte for a comment.

Forte said we have an issue on my street where cars oftentimes overhang my driveway. And I just wanted to compliment all of your officers. They always come and resolve the situation immediately. Lieutenant Buchmann said thank you. Forte said and they don’t issue tickets, they just tell people and they move immediately. We have just big trucks, so it’s hard to get in and out. But I just want to compliment them. They always come in a minute, and they’re really kind and understanding. And they, like, always make it so it’s no drama with the person who’s parked, because we have a spot that’s one spot that people double-park. So, I just want to compliment all of the officers. Lieutenant Buchmann said thank you, I appreciate that, that’s good to hear. Forte said yeah.

Wylie said anybody else on council?

No comments.

Wylie said anybody in the public?

No comments.

Wylie said Lieutenant Buchmann, thank you very much for coming. Lieutenant Buchmann said oh, thanks for having me. Wylie said you’re welcome to stay around if you’d like to. Forte said they might take a few more pictures of you.

Agenda Item #9 – Consent Agenda (video time mark 0:14:02):

    • 10-12-2026 – Final Minutes, Regular City Council Meeting (page 5/39 of the council packet)
    • 10-26-2026 – Draft Minutes, Regular City Council Meeting (page 7/39 of the council packet)
    • 11-09-2026 – Treasurer’s Report (page 9/39 of the council packet)
    • 11-05-2026 – Check Disbursement Report – 10-01-2026 – 10-31-2026 (page 10/39 of the council packet)

Wylie said Item #9 is consent agenda. This includes final minutes of the October 12 regular meeting, draft minutes of the October 26 regular meeting, the treasurer’s report from November 9, 2026. And I’ll need a motion and a second to approve the consent agenda.

Motion by Jones; second Forte.

Wylie said and discussion or comments from council members?

No comments.

Wylie said from the public?

No comments.

The consent agenda was approved by unanimous voice vote.

Wylie said the consent agenda is approved.

Agenda Item #10, Unfinished Business (video time mark 0:14:38):

Wylie said Item #10 is unfinished business, which there is none.

Agenda Item #11, New Business (video time mark 0:14:42):

Item #11a – Discussion: Election Results, Next Steps (video time mark 0:14:45):

    • Unaudited Election Results, November 2026 General Election (page 17/39 of the council packet)

Wylie said Item #11, #11a is discussion, election results, next steps. And I assume Guillen and Smith, perhaps together. (To Guillen), Wylie said  are you going to be talking about first, but then Smith?

Smith said so, this is a summary that I put together just to capture the results of Tuesday’s election. But it includes, as shown here, the early voting, nine days of early voting. So, we have 749 registered voters in the city. 73 voted during the nine days of early voting. That’s an increase from November, or from August. We had 226 absentee. 246 ballots were sent out. 226 returned them. And in person, we had 274. All adds up to 573 voters, which is 76.5% voting rate. So that’s a very good number. And we’re very happy with the turnout of this election. We had a lot of younger voters, too, I would just add as a, as a side comment. It was good to see all the younger voters turning out in the city, many of them apparently for their first time.

Smith said on the city council positions, we had four open seats, as you know. Al Avery had 204 votes. Sue Wylie had 282. And Forte had 250. And Richard Bisio is our registered write-in. We had other write-ins, but he was the only registered write-in. We had 34 votes for Bisio. So those are the four winning votes. And those will be sworn in in December. We reported in the last meeting that will happen, according to the new act, the Home Rule Act, we will vote or swear them in in early December. If we don’t get a chance to do it before the meeting, we’ll do it in the meeting on that first meeting, I think is the next – Wylie said I think it’s December 11? Smith said maybe it is. So, it’s – Forte said second Monday? Wylie said second Monday. Smith said it’s the 14th. Wylie said 14th. 14th, OK. Smith said OK. So that’s the council seats.

Smith said and then, as you know by now, the police, fire, emergency services millage proposal failed. We had a very close vote, a difference of 25 votes. We actually had 30 under or over votes. So those are excluded from the counts. But in total, we had 259 yes, 284 no. So now, what I was hoping to engage council on is a discussion of where we go from here.

Smith said so, in my opinion, we have three options. One would be to do nothing. Just drop our police and fire coverage and live without it. The township that surrounds us does still have coverage on both police and fire. Their millage, their police millage passed. And their fire wasn’t up for renewal. So, they still have coverage. But is it an option to have no coverage? Well, I guess technically it is. But we did receive a note, if I didn’t say this in the last council meeting, we did receive a note from, by way of the, I think it was the elections bureau or it was the treasurer’s, I think, forum that don’t count on the state police. They don’t have manpower. They don’t have budget. So, thinking that the state police is a safety net is an inaccurate statement. But theoretically, we could reach out to the state and see what kind of financial arrangements could be met. So that’s option one. I don’t think it’s a good option. But technically, it is an option.

Smith said option two would be to wait until May of 2027 to have a special election. At that time, we would be able to present the full story. As you know, the awkward part from my standpoint in presenting this in several informational sessions, the awkward point is we, we were talking about a millage increase, but we could not talk about the offsetting decrease. I mentioned it. I said it’s planned. But I couldn’t say definitively there will be exactly a 5.5 mill reduction on the operating side after we add this new police millage. The ballot wording only referred to the 7-mill increase. And I think a lot of people just read that as, OK, we already have 11.4 mills. And you’re just going to add 7, so you’re going to be at 18. We never envisioned that possibility. But some voters could certainly have made that interpretation. And some did. They told me that. So, in May, if we had a special election in May, we could say definitively in the ballot wording that there will not only be a new millage increase of 7 mills for police and fire and emergency services, but there will also be a millage reduction on the operating side, because then at that time, we would know what our 2027 budgetary needs are. And we could say exactly what the offsetting reduction would be. Then you’d have the whole story presented to the voters. That, I think, is a key advantage of having a vote in May to consider the whole picture and maybe get a completely different voter turnout and voter response.

Smith said the third option would be to do a special assessment. So, it wouldn’t be a vote of the people. The city council would have the power to initiate a special assessment for police, fire, and emergency services. It’s been talked about in previous council meetings that some of the council members voiced a concern about doing that. We would prefer that the people speak and not just city council make this decision on their own. You can see that the vote was very close. And maybe city council would say, we still want to entertain that option. Or maybe you want to see a hybrid of options 2 and 3. Put the special election in May. That would probably require pulling the budgetary process forward from May back to maybe March. So, we’d have that done and solidified in March. Then do a special election in May. If it doesn’t pass then, theoretically, you could go to plan C, which would be a special assessment if that’s council’s wish.

Smith said so, those are the three options. I’m just laying them out. Obviously, council makes the decisions. I do not. I will carry out whatever decisions council makes. And at that point, I think I’d just like to open it up for discussion and see what council thinks. May’s a long ways away yet, but I don’t think it would hurt to get started on this as early as possible.

Wylie said it’ll come fast. Just like this one came fast. If we do a special election in May, how many years? I, what’s the end date on this? Smith said it would still be a three-year village proposal. This, what we were voting on here was the ‘27, ‘28, ‘29 fiscal years. [Clarkston Sunshine comment: The ballot provided for a 4-year millage, going to June 30, 2031. The city consistently misrepresented this as a 3-year millage.] So, we have coverage right now. Just maybe clarify, a point of clarification. We have police coverage and contractual agreements that cover us through June of 2027. So, we’re not going to lose police and fire immediately. Nothing will happen. No changes will happen between now and June of 2027. We’d like to get this on the books, though. So come July 1, the new tax bills go out, theoretically at a higher rate if it passes. And the new police services will be funded, and fire and emergency services, too. So, if I didn’t make that clear earlier, I apologize. The thought is that we have coverage through June. If we had a special election in May. There’s still time, if we get voter approval, to have this in place for July 1 start. And it would be three years after that that it would go through. [Clarkston Sunshine comment: If the city intends a 3-year millage, it will need to revise the ballot language to say that. If it uses the same ballot language, it should stop calling it a 3-year millage and call it what it is, a 4-year millage.]

Wylie said so, I guess my concern about how long is because when we discussed the previous millage that was just on the ballot, we were going to have 7 mills. And then each year, determine how much we could reduce our budget by depending on other increases. So, we were kind of, we’re freezing everything for three years. Smith said well, not necessarily. The 7-mill increase for police and fire, that would be frozen. It’s going to be knocked down slightly by Headlee all three years. Wylie said yeah. Smith said but it’ll basically stay the 7 mills. The operating mills, that is set every year independently based on the budgetary needs. So, if we were to come forward in the offsetting reduction in year 1 of this 3-year window, year 1, we’re going to do a 5.5 mill reduction. Year two, maybe it’s a 5.2 or a 5.8 mill [reduction]. Wylie said we would actually state it on the ballot. Smith said well, we’d only be able to say year 1, because we would have the budget done for year 1, 2027. Wylie said OK. Smith said but we wouldn’t be able to state beyond that until we get closer to that year when the millages are set for operating use.

Wylie said so, there’s still that nefarious, quite open area, just like there was in this? Smith said for years 2 and 3. Wylie said for years 2 and 3. Smith said year 1 would be firm, but years 2 and 3 – Wylie said OK – (continuing), Smith said your point’s well taken. They’d be somewhat open-ended. Rodgers said I think that’s what gets people anxious, is that open-endedness.

Jones said and also, if I could just chime in here, from talking to people over the weekend and seeing what people are saying on social, people just flat out don’t understand what they are being asked. The ballot language is murky at best. And then trying to explain what all it’s going to do. I mean, the fact that you just had to clarify that we still do have police coverage until June, that kind of is, is a bad thing. So, I think that regardless of how we proceed, whether it’s do nothing or whatever, we’ve got to, we’ve got to educate the public better about this. I mean, even if, I feel confused now about what all this is, is doing. And so, I think we need to take a step back. Not, you know, too far, but we need to edu-, we need to basically explain this like people are five years old, because it is very confusing. People are confusing what happened with Independence Township vote, with ours. And so, I think that providing some clarity about what it actually is that’s going to happen, as far as you can. I know that whatever with the budget, but people just from the jump off, I don’t think understand this ballot proposal.

Wylie said of course, there were two, three meetings that people could attend. There was information on the website. I mean, we could have done more, but I think that was probably the biggest problem. Rodgers said wasn’t it in the Clarkston News too? Smith said it was. It’s been on several channels. I really don’t know what to say to that. I put so much time in on this – Wylie said I know you did – (continuing), Smith said over the last two months. Try to get the word out. Maybe there’s better spokesmen than me that could do a better job. I’m not precluding that.

Rodgers said how many people came to the, I know the one that I was at had like 4 or 5 people. Smith said well, there were more than that. I think there were, I think, one had 12, one had 10, and the last one had 3. So, diminishing returns, for sure.

Wylie said I agree with you. Jones said but I also think it happened very quickly. Wylie said but also, ballot proposals are murky. Jones said no, it is, but it also, you said it happened in two months, so it happened quickly. So, I think that also probably was part of the issue, too, is that we were faced with a deadline of having to get it all on there, and that can contribute to it. And I think now that we know that we’ve got this, like, I think that is something that we need to keep top of mind if we want to be successful without having to go to a special assessment.

Wylie said we knew from the very beginning, when we started talking about this at budget meetings, we said that it’s going to be a hard, it’s going to be a tough sell. And we talked about even hiring, I mean, I said, we need to hire somebody who, a public relations company, or somebody to explain this to the public.

Rodgers said well, timing was bad, too, because a lot of things were happening. I mean, people brought some concerns about not seeing police, and like the noise level, the e-bikes, the e-motos, the speeding on Holcomb, and not having any police presence. And that kind of, at least those that spoke with me, were not happy about that, like, we’re going to have to pay more money, and we don’t get what we think we deserve anyhow, you know. And I mean, I think the explanations are fair. There’s only so much staff that you can, can do. But I think that kind of that summertime, too much was being brought to our attention, and then asking for more money for what they perceived as maybe not being – Smith said a priority. Rodgers said and then on top of that, not being able to say exactly how much the budget was going to, you know, increase in the next couple of years.

Smith said I could argue that in any given year, any given year, let’s say we forget this whole police and fire for a minute. In any given year, there is some question as to what the millage rate will be. When we bring the budget public hearing forward in May, it could be that we have a huge requirement of, you know, money in the next fiscal year for x, or y, or z, whatever it is. So, there’s always a possibility that your millage rate could fluctuate around based on what the, the budgetary needs are. We try to keep it in check, but if the fund balance doesn’t have the wherewithal to absorb it, and it’s running out of that ability, then we’re going to have to fluctuate the millage rate up and down to, you know, make the numbers balance. So that’s always a possibility. This story, put the two together, it makes a really hard discussion to have. I feel that if we had a special election in May, we could at least have year 1 defined very clearly. Years 2 and 3 would be still somewhat up in the air, but year 1 would be, I think, easier to explain. Will that make a difference? I don’t know.

Smith said love to have some further input from some of the people if they’d be open-minded or open with their comments. Some of the people that voted no, I’d love to hear from them. I look at the 4 or 5 other communities in Oakland County that had police or emergency service millages in place that all failed in August in the primary and all passed in November. And my reaction to that is that in that 3 or 4 months, those communities reacted. They listened to what the residents that voted no, listened to what they were saying, and they reacted one way or the other. Was it a millage rate change? Was it some other component that the residents were expressing concern about? But somehow, they reacted. So, they had two shots at it. I had one. If we had it in May, that would be my second shot and my ability to react to some of the no rationale that might be, might be out there. I’d love to hear from people if they’d be open with me and say, look, we heard your story, Smith, but we don’t believe this or we don’t trust that or we just think this is wrong. That would give us an opportunity in May to address those, those concerns.

Forte said could we just do the request not to be the 7 and the deduction eventually? Can we just ask for what we need to increase by? Smith said so, leave it in the operating millage, you’re saying, and just an increase to cover that. Forte said yes. Smith said it is an option. It is. It’s a good point, Forte. We could do that. Forte said I think that would be the simplest. Smith said it would still be an increase. Forte said yeah, but there’d be a lack of ambiguity. You know what I mean?

Forte said and then my second question is, I know we’ve talked around this and I can’t remember where we ended. Do we end up getting quotes from other municipalities that could support us for police and fire, like physical quotes, or is that not possible? Smith said it’s really not really even feasible. To contract with another city that has police services, say Waterford has their own police service, would they support us? It’s a drive from Waterford to here, and would they come up here for such a small community? My feedback is that no, that they’re not gonna do that on the police side. Really, the Oakland County Sheriff is the only viable alternative. On the fire side, there is the North Oakland Fire Authority. Here again, you’re looking at a response time setback. Wylie said they’re even farther than Waterford. Smith said they’re even farther than Waterford. So, getting a response, whether it’s a fire or an EMS [emergency medical services] call, you have to expect a delay from what we’re experiencing today. Today we get pretty darn good response from Independence Township Fire Department.

Wylie recognized Jones for a comment.

Jones said I’m sorry, when you say feedback, is that confirmed feedback in terms of the call? Like, is that what you actually have received? Like, or is that just people have said, oh, it’s gonna be longer? Smith said no, that’s just math. Jones said no, no, no, I know it’s just math, but I’m saying, like, have you actually spoken with Waterford in terms of would they even entertain the possibility? Smith said no, I have not. Jones said OK. Smith said I have not seriously. I’ve had some casual discussion with some of the other officers. Is this a possibility? But I have not actually talked with Waterford. Jones said so serious conversations haven’t been entertained.

Wylie said and I think the feeling on what we discussed in the council is that we want local emergency police and fire services not going out to – Jones said because I know we talked about Holly and things like that too, so, yeah.

Smith said yeah. In an emergency, whether it’s police, fire, or EMS, response time is critically important. We could, could explore if council wants me to get quotes and get real answers, yes, no, maybe, kind of answers from some of these other communities. Forte said yeah, I would. I wanna see what the numbers add up to be. Wylie said but I think that’s something as a council, we need to decide, do we really want that? Because when we’ve discussed it before, the council has mostly said, we don’t want to go that far. Forte said yeah, I get that. The reason why I bring it up is, if we go down this route of going to another vote in May and it gets voted down again, I want to have everything ready.

Jones said well, and I’d like to add onto that, I’ve literally been asking for that research for like a year, a year and a half, and I thought that it had been done, and now I’m hearing that it hadn’t, or it was just like casual conversation. So yeah, I mean, like, that was why I initially said no, because I thought we had gotten hard feedback on what the other townships were. But if we haven’t, then I think that we should do, again, the due diligence on it, so that we know what all of the options are. Smith said no, it was a casual conversation, it was not, I don’t recall a motion ever being made to, Smith, go get quotes from these other agencies.

Wylie said anything else from council members?

Forte said do we need a motion to move forward on getting quotes? Smith said I would like, this is gonna be a very time-consuming effort. Wylie said why don’t we wait until we get, we’ve got three council members missing tonight, and I think, I know Quisenberry especially, maybe all three of them would like to be part of that discussion, so I would say we wait until we have. Forte said table until next meeting? Wylie said table until – Forte said is that OK? Smith said yeah. Forte said OK. Wylie said OK.

Wylie said anybody else on council members?

Wylie said my personal feeling is we should go for the May 2027, try to get some more – Smith said feedback. Wylie said yeah, feedback, like you mentioned, find out what people were looking for. I know that’s what Independence Township did, and they also, it was like all hands on deck. They were pushing everybody, they got, they really got the public involved. I don’t know as much what Lake Orion or other communities did, but I would try to stay on top of what Independence Township was doing to get the vote. And they got some people to pay for signs and put ads out and things like that.

Rodgers said and I know, Smith, you worked your butt off – Wylie said yes – (continuing), Rodgers said these last few weeks, but Jones is also right that, I mean, when you looked in social media, the responses to this was like, yeah, and what about those flock cameras? We have no flock cameras. Jones said yeah, I get that, yeah. Rodgers said so, there is an ignorance out there of what we’re really talking about. And I know that you tried as hard as you could in the six weeks or how many ever weeks it was to get people to come to those meetings, but they just didn’t. Like, they just didn’t. Jones said no, because I really liked the person who suggested that we contract with Independence Township for our fire and emergency services. Wylie said oh! Jones said which I told them, we do. So. Rodgers said so yeah, I think maybe having enough time to, and for us, too, to know exactly what we’re asking for.

Forte said yeah, the calls will probably come in above, you know what I mean? It just might be good to know where we are in the range, you know what I mean? Rodgers said I just worry about the distance, the response time. Forte said yeah. Rodgers said our houses are like matchboxes. Forte said oh yeah, when one goes up, that’ll be all of them. Rodgers said yeah, waiting for somebody to come from – Forte said for sure.

Wylie said but it sounds like we may have perhaps two considerations as far as doing a vote in May of 2027. Do something similar to what we had where we have a separate millage for police, fire, emergency services, and we’re still, you’ve got an operating budget, or as Forte suggested, perhaps just increase the operating budget on that. Forte said so that would be a fourth option, which would be just to do the, well, that would fall under 2. Wylie said or 2A and 2B. Forte said 2A and 2B, yeah.

Wylie said do we have to have elections on Tuesdays? Is that? Smith said that’s the state. Guillen said the first Tuesday after the first Monday. Wylie said has to be, okay, so that would be May 4th, maybe? Probably May 11th. That’s right, I think. I was looking up dates. And roughly how much would it cost us to run an election, anybody know? Guillen said just about $10,000. Wylie said $10,000? That’s May 11th.

Forte said and no one wants to talk about it, but at some point, we’ve got to talk about, like, if none of this were to go through, like if we didn’t do this special assessment, what would we do? You know what I mean? Smith said if there’s not a vote of the people or a special assessment that approves this, then you’re without police and fire. And that, again, don’t count on the state police. They’ve made it clear. They don’t have manpower or budget to do this. So, no one’s gonna come to me and say, you know, the goodness of their hearts. We’d be without, and insurance rates, and individual homeowners’ insurance rates are gonna skyrocket.

Wylie said but if the election doesn’t, if you don’t get an election, then council will look at a special assessment. Although there was some discussion in the past that if we had a special assessment, whether a certain percentage of people had signed a petition – Smith said 10% – Wylie said 10% of people signed a petition, then it has to go to a vote. Smith said correct. So, yes, there is that provision. Gerry [Fisher, city attorney] said it’s just about the 10% of the vote of the people. 10%, I guess it’d be a petition of the people, could override council’s, and ask that it be, go back to a vote of the people.

Wylie said is that based on the numbers of voting in the previous election? 80 people? Smith said I’m not sure. Is it 10% of the, do you know? Wylie said registered voters? Smith said is it 10% of the registered voters, or? Kristen Kolb [assistant city attorney] said I don’t know. Wylie said OK, we’re talking maybe 80 or 90 people. Not that it matters, but. OK.

Smith said I’m open to other feedback. I really felt like I was out on a limb by myself this whole time. I’m a little frustrated about that. So, yes, I was certainly hopeful that it would pass, but now that it’s failed, it’s frustrating to me that there weren’t more resources put on this, but. It is what it is at this point.

Wylie said any comments from the public? Wylie said yes, sir, I’ve got a gentleman back there, and then Bisio. Go ahead, sir.

An unidentified man (later identified as Mr. Sims) said so, something is, you know, an idea just came up. The special assessment is gonna be specifically for the police and fire. Wylie said it could be. Sims said could be. So, it’s very specific, and I think that was one of the reasons why it didn’t pass, because it was convoluted, intertwined. If you make it straightforward, and saying here’s the special assessment, here’s what we need, this is our assessment, and if you get it. So, the opportunity there is, for option three, is if you do that, and it just goes forward, and no one does the petition, you save $10,000. Wylie said true. Sims said so, that was just my quick idea, and then this came up of, hey, it’s a $10,000 thing. I mean, everyone knows that we need police and fire. Everyone needs to understand that it’s gone up. I think it’s more the intertwining of the dollars, more so than approving the additional amount. I think that was the issue. You know, saying, trust me, I’m gonna do this magic back here, and trust me. Again, no one wants to trust anyone. So, so, put it in black and white. If you put an assessment, put it in black and white, and take that forward. If people don’t like it, then, you know, if you make it very black and white, because that’s all you’re gonna do for the election anyhow, you’re gonna try to make it more black and white. I think you still need to make it more black and white than just 1 year. I think, well, I don’t know, but police and fire costs are somewhat defined for X amount of period. I mean, there’s some fluctuation, you can share that, and move forward that way, versus, you know, throwing, you know, all these special elections, the early voting, to me, is money thrown out the window, that it might be a way to save money, just an idea. Wylie said no, it’s a good point, thank you. Forte said no, that is a good point. Wylie said something you said, I can’t remember now. You said something that made me want to ask you something, but now I don’t remember, but thank you.

Wylie said Lieutenant, I’m sorry, Bisio, then Lieutenant.

Wylie said oh, I’m sorry. Smith said I wanted to ask you, the challenge there is it’s a special assessments challenge. You get 10% of the voters that say, no, I don’t like that. Then, where do you go? If we did a special assessment, to your point, I would say, then do it early, so that I could still have a May special election, as a second shot at it. Because if you do a special assessment, and 10% of the voters come back and say, that’s illegal, and they challenge it, and they win, then you’ve got nothing. Wylie said yeah.

Wylie said I remember what I was gonna say, is that anytime we talked about special assessments at meetings in the past, it was always, we wanted to let the public, the voters vote on it. We didn’t want council to make that kind of decision. So that’s what I was gonna say.

(To Sims), Wylie said and you had something else to add? Sims said yeah, I mean, I would do it right away, because everyone’s wondering, what’s gonna happen to our police and fire? I mean, I didn’t know before today, that we were covered until June. You know, I’m not sure how many people know that. People think, OK, now, we didn’t vote for it, so now we don’t have it. When does that start? Wylie said thank you.

Wylie recognized Bisio for a comment. Bisio said yes. Wylie said and then, Lieutenant Buchmann, after that.

Bisio said I find it discouraging that all you want to talk about is raising taxes again. And you should not ask taxpayers for another tax increase until you’ve explored all of the options. I’ve got two areas of examination that I think you should focus on. First, you can get an objective, independent review of city finances. You can ask the state treasurer to do a financial review and prepare a report that would examine whether the city is under what they call probable financial distress. And from the presentations and the discussion that we’ve seen, we are on an unsustainable course where expenditures are increasing, but revenues are not increasing to keep up with the expenditures. And the question is, what do you do to deal with that? You can spend down the fund balance, but that’s not a long-term solution. But you can get some kind of independent, objective review to make a recommendation to you. Because as far as I know, it seems like we’re all amateurs here about how to do municipal finance and administration. Maybe the MML [Michigan Municipal League], maybe SEMCOG [Southeast Michigan Council of Governments] has some resources that we can draw on. But I would urge you to do something like that to just get some independent, objective review of the city’s long-term financial situation.

Bisio said secondly, I haven’t heard anything here or anything during the whole campaign about seriously cutting costs. Let’s get serious about that. Let’s explore alternatives for police services. It’s come out here that we haven’t really done that. Waterford, their fire department covers Pontiac. I don’t know how that works, but if you’re talking about police services from Waterford, we’re closer than Pontiac. I don’t know what other alternatives there are. Most of the townships and cities around us contract with Oakland County. I don’t know if there’s some direct arrangement that you can make with Oakland County or perhaps with Springfield, who contracts with Oakland County. Maybe you can make a better deal with them than you can with Independence. But those are all alternatives that you should be looking at.

Bisio said and we should look at employee costs. The pie chart that Smith used in his presentation showed a big piece of pie for police and fire. But it also showed several pieces of pie for employee expenses. And if you put them all together, that’s almost equal to what we’re spending on police and fire. You can look at combining positions. When I was first on the council, we had a clerk/treasurer, one person who did both functions. Before my time, we had Art Pappas, who did everything. We didn’t have any other city officers. Somehow, I think there can be a combination, or perhaps a farming out of some of the functions. The city of Pleasant Ridge, for example, uses Plante Moran as their treasurer. You should explore an alternative, like having an accounting firm perform the treasurer’s functions. I don’t know if that’s cheaper. But you don’t know that either. Wylie thanked Bisio.

Bisio said I have a couple of other – (interrupting Bisio), Wylie said actually, I didn’t set my timer, but we have a three-minute limit on public comments. Bisio said OK, I’d like you to waive that three-minute limit, since I’m going to be on the council in December. Wylie said OK, you’ll be on the council in December, and you can make your comments then. Bisio said you don’t want to hear what I have to say? OK. Wylie said OK, thank you.

[Clarkston Sunshine comment: Bisio was elected to the council in the November election. State law says a newly-elected official can’t take office until December 1 after the general election. Thus, council member elect Bisio made his comments as a member of the public and was subjected to the council’s arbitrary 3-minute limit on public comments.]

Wylie recognized Lieutenant Buchmann for a comment.

Lieutenant Buchmann said I’ll be brief. The comment about, it’s not a comment, but the statement about not seeing us or not, I don’t like that comment, not saying that I agree with you. I don’t like that, so I would like to talk to somebody that we can fix that problem, because that’s a fixable problem that we can work with. OK, I was not aware that would be, that that was an issue, and if that is an issue, we want to fix that. OK, I don’t want to just sit around and do nothing. I want that to be addressed. I, as far as millages, I am not a money person, and I have never done millages, but I did a lot for the township millage, so I learned a lot. Now, I can’t come out and say, because I’m a government employee, I can’t come out and say, you should vote for it, or you can’t vote for it, but when you go out and talk to some of the people that possibly voted no, I can go with you, or we can set up a time where we all meet, and I can offer to the people what services that we use, or what that we offer, and maybe that would put more peace at mind. Whatever you, whatever you guys think is you need from me, I’m willing to help, OK? That’s pretty much my only comment. Wylie and Forte said thank you.

Wylie said anybody else in the public?

Steve Hargis said could I? (To Hargis), Wylie said yes, yes.

Hargis said I would like to say that, personally, I think one of the reasons maybe some people voted no on this issue was because the feeling that we’re not really getting the service that we’re paying for. I live on Main Street, 55 North, and we have a tremendous amount of high-speed traffic, a lot of noise, especially in the summertime. Of course, now things are slowing down. It’s getting, you know, cold, and people are staying in more, but we really don’t have much coverage of the City of the Village of Clarkston relative to keeping what I consider peace and security of, of the community, and, I don’t know, I voted yes because I thought, well, you know, this is the best thing we need to do. We need to get the coverage that we can and move on down the road, see if we can fix things along the way, but I think that probably, that was some of the motivation for voting no was because people don’t feel that we’re really getting the service we’re paying for here. That’s my comment. Wylie said thank you. Hargis said thank you. Steve Hargis, by the way. Wylie said yes.

Wylie said anybody else like to make a comment in public? I guess or council. OK, anybody? All right, thank you.

An unidentified man said I actually, sorry, I’m on Zoom. I have one question. If in May, there’s not a lot of time, it’s like three weeks before June, right? If the special election goes down, right, how long do we have or how long does it take to implement the special assessment? And two, you know, it sounds almost like it’s best to do the special assessment early because if there is a challenge to it, you’re gonna spend $10K. There’s not a challenge to it, you save $10K. So, it seems like, and if you’re gonna be doing the plain language anyway, it sounds like that’s probably the best option to just do it early and get it over with. Wylie said well, thank you.

Wylie said and anybody else? Forte said there’s a, oh, another one. (To Forte), Wylie said what’s that? Forte said I thought there was a comment on the Zoom. There isn’t. Smith said oh, yeah, no, I don’t see any comments.

Kristen Kolb (assistant city attorney) said may I? Wylie said yes, Kolb. Kolb said I did a quick check. Wylie said OK. Kolb said for, if the council initiates a special assessment district. Wylie said OK. Kolb said a petition signed by 10% of the landowners within the city. Wylie said landowners? Kolb said that is the statute. Wylie said so, is that one person per piece of property? 10% of owners of the land in the district, which would be the entire city. OK, so Rodgers and her husband own a piece of property. Do they each get to sign the petition? Or is that part of the, it doesn’t specify? Kolb said it doesn’t specify. Wylie said OK. Kolb said I’ll look into that a little bit more, but it’s not based on. Wylie said not based on a vote? Kolb said electors or how many people vote in the last election. It’s based on the land area, which is. The law that allows the city to create an SAD [special assessment district] is based on township law for special assessments that typically covers things like paving roads and extending water and sewer. So, it’s not the cleanest, but that’s what it provides. Wylie said OK. OK.

(To Bisio), Wylie said did you have a comment or question?

Bisio said one question. Wylie said go ahead. How is that 10% determined? Is it each parcel gets one vote? Kolb said that’s what she’s asking. Jones said that’s what she’s asking. She doesn’t know the answer. Kolb said I don’t know the law. Reading the statute on its face, it’s not clear. Bisio said no, I think it’s not. An unidentified man online aid it’s most likely one vote per landowner. If they’re joint owners, they probably each get a vote. And it’s because they, when you do a special assessment, it’s a flat assessment. It’s not like a, it’s not like a millage where it’s based on property values. I believe a special assessment is just a flat one. Everybody pays the same thing, which is why you get the landowner vote. Kolb said that’s not necessarily true. Wylie said well, we can’t, we don’t have the answer tonight, but at least we have a starting point.

Wylie recognized Forte for a comment.

Forte said there was one thing Bisio brought up that I want to, like, kind of circle back to. The state independent financial review. Greg [Coté, treasurer], what do you think of that? Coté said I’m open to anything. Sure. Forte said yeah. I mean, if it’s free and we can start that. Coté said it’s probably not free. Forte said OK, yeah. But is it, is it through SEMCOG or who is it through? Coté said probably Michigan Treasury or the state. Smith said we can reach out to all three, MML, SEMCOG, and the state treasury department. Forte said just to see if, like, what they think of our situation and what they would recommend. You know what I mean? Coté said yeah. Smith said yeah. That would be helpful to tell the story to our residents. Forte said yeah. I want to have like all the evidence before we make any next decisions or steps. You know what I mean? Just personally. Smith said yeah, I agree.

Wylie said anybody else?

Wylie said so, it looks like we’ve maybe, probably, I’ll tell you, our next meeting is the last meeting in November. Smith said yup. Wylie said and can we get some more information for that next meeting, find out about the special assessment district, how that ten, you know, we’re trying to just cover it. Maybe nobody will even try to get a petition. How many pieces of property, about 400? Coté said 455 residents, homes. Wylie said OK. Kolb said how many parcels? Wylie said how many parcels? I know you’ve done, I’m putting you on the spot. Kolb said instead of a 10% parcel, it’s 10% of the land, so. Wylie said so, it’s fewer than the voters. Might be 40 – (Coté made an unintelligible comment) – (continuing), Wylie said 40 people might be able to sign a petition. OK. OK, so, we need information on that. (To Coté), Wylie said we need information on, if you could look up to see what thing that Bisio brought up. Coté said yeah. Wylie said if there is a possibility. Coté said yep. Wylie said different ways. I kind of think what we’re looking at is, well, we’re looking at both possibilities, special assessment district and the possibility of the 7-mill election. So, I guess we have to look at all, start looking at both possibilities. So, if we can talk about that. Will you guys be able to get all that together by our next meeting? (To Kolb), Wylie said are you coming to the next meeting? Kolb said I don’t know, but I think I can. Wylie said or at least pass that information on to us. Kolb said yeah. Yeah. Wylie said and Coté, you’ll be able to get that by, that’s two weeks. Coté said yeah.

Wylie said anybody else?

No comments.

Item #11b – Resolution: Clerk Guillen Attending the December 1-3 MAMC [Michigan Association of Municipal Clerks] Academy (video time mark 0:58:25):

    • Resolution – MAMC [Michigan Association of Municipal Clerks] Master Academy in December 2026 (page 18/39 of the council packet) 
    • 2026 MAMC Master Academy Schedule Highlights (page 19/39 of the council packet) 
    • About Master Academy (page 20/39 of the council packet) 
    • Agenda (page 21/39 of the council packet)

Wylie said OK. We’re at #11b, Resolution, Angie Guillen, or Clerk Guillen, attending the December 1 through 3 MAMC [Michigan Association of Municipal Clerks] Academy. And there is a resolution.

(Wylie read the resolution.)

Wylie said am I reading something different than what you guys said? Smith said so, the numbers did change today. (To Forte), said so, the previous one that I gave you, had $200 a night. The correct number is $105.00. Wylie said that’s what we were trying to correct.

Wylie said OK, and then we’ll need somebody to resolve and then support.

Motion by Jones; second Rodgers.

Wylie said and discussion or comments from council members?

Wylie said I think this is important to do. Elections is an important part of the democratic process. It requires that we have a certified, competent clerk who knows what she’s doing. And these conferences, I think, make a big difference for that. And you’ve done that.

Wylie said anybody else have comments?

Jones said know election laws. Wylie said yeah, know election laws. Wylie said and I think it’s been changed. Jones said it’s, it’s, it’s, it’s ever-changing and she’s gotta stay up on it.

Wylie said yes, any comments or questions from the public?

Sims said is there an early voting requirement? Wylie said a requirement? It is, as of – Sims said so, every municipality has to have it. Guillen said so, for a state or federal election, it’s required. For a local, say it’s just council, it’s not. That’s the reason why I chose to do early voting myself, to be fiscally responsible to residents and to also provide where they can come right to their city and vote. Because they made, so the county made us have a 10 day or 9 days of early voting for the council and we didn’t have to have that. It’s not required by the law. Sims said so, the way you did it really encouraged – Guillen said saving money. Sims said yeah, maybe some costs, but not a lot of costs. Guillen said saving. Sims said yeah, so that was my biggest thing is, if we didn’t have to do it, don’t do it. It seems like a waste of – Wylie said yeah, the past, what was it, two years ago, that? Guillen said oh, 2022, the residents of Michigan voted to have that. Wylie said I don’t think we knew what we were getting into.

Wylie recognized Bisio for a comment.

Bisio said yeah, I noticed in the material that there was a deadline and a late fee of $75. I don’t know if that applies. And I would ask what additional costs there might be for mileage, meals, and anything else which are not included in the resolution. And other than the election information, which I believe you can probably get from the Secretary of State, I would ask if this is necessary or useful for the clerk’s position now and for what she does on a day-to-day basis.

Jones said I think given the scrutiny that the clerk’s position faces, that it’s important for her to have the most up-to-date training and be going to these things.

Wylie said any other, no, any other questions or comments from the public or council?

Wylie recognized Forte for a comment.

Forte said I’m wondering if any of these trainings are online, like, if we could take – Guillen said they’re not, they’re in person. This is part of my continuing education to excel me to the next level of certification. So, I’m working on my master’s through that, and this is part of that. Forte said OK, and so what is the difference between, like, what you have now and then – Guillen said so, once you’ve already graduated, this is continuing education every year that they have in December. Forte said OK. Guillen said it’s part of being a professional. Rodgers said yeah, it’s kind of like – Forte said I know what continuing education is, thank you. But, but even I have to do that, but we have online courses that we can take. We don’t have to go to – Guillen said there’s no online courses for this. It’s all in person. Forte said OK. Guillen said you get points per day for attending. Forte said OK. Guillen said and you have to attend, or you don’t, you have to finish the conference, or you don’t get your points for your certification.

Bisio said just one thing about the election. If you look at the schedule, the election information is a half day on the second day. So, I would question whether you need a three-day conference. Wylie said OK, thank you.

Wylie said anybody else, questions or comments?

No comments.

Wylie said OK, we’ve got a resolution by Jones, supported by Rodgers.

Wylie said and Guillen, if you would take the roll call, please.

Jones, Rodgers, and Wylie voted yes.

Forte voted no.

Wylie said and we need four. So, the resolution is defeated.

Jones said I’ll give you credit right now. Wylie said OK.

Jones said I’m sorry. I just want to say that I think that’s disappointing. Because that’s training that she actually needs. And like the other thing, where we should have had Smith stay home for that one when we approved for him to go, which is, and yeah, no, that’s, this is so dumb. That’s disappointing. Wylie said don’t. I’m sorry. I understand you can be emotional, but just gotta watch when we talk to each other. Jones said yeah, no, it’s disappointing. It’s disappointing.

Item #11c – Resolution: South Main Street Retaining Wall Repairs (video time mark 1:05:01):

    • Resolution – South Main Street Retaining Wall Repairs (page 22/39 of the council packet) 
    • Bid Comparison (page 23/39 of the council packet) 
    • 10-30-2026 – Bid Proposal, Smathers Services, LLC (page 24/39 of the council packet, including photos)

Wylie said OK. Item #11c is resolution, South Main Street retaining wall repair. We’ve got the resolution.

(Wylie read the resolution.)

Wylie said and I’ll need a resolution and support.

Motion by Jones; second Wylie.

Wylie said and we’ve got some pictures. The quotes are attached, well, quotes attached and there’s some pictures. Oh, the explanation matters are written. I guess it’s part of the written estimate and there’s some pictures of the wall, different views and I think there’s also pictures of the stone wall. Yeah, stone wall.

Wylie said so, discussion or comments from council members.

(To Smith), Rodgers said it’s like not apples to apples here, right? Is that, am I reading that correctly? The $12,050 from Smathers, the cheapest one from the other five people but four of which never quoted anything. Cheapest one was Michigan Chimney Repair, that was $9,500. But Smathers is doing something in addition and why didn’t they just give us a quote for what we asked for or did we ask for that?

Smith said they did and so here’s a – they did break out their quotes. So, if we just had them do the brick retaining wall, which is what Michigan Chimney Repair had quoted at $9,500, Smathers is $6,285. So, they’re over $3,000 cheaper for just the brick wall and if that’s all you wanna do, you can stop there. The stone wall though, when he came out, Chris came out to look at the brick wall, he says, yes, I can do that. And he then looked at the stone walls because the neighbors that are adjacent to the stone walls had come out, seen all this activity and asked, why aren’t we repairing the stone walls as well? They don’t seem to be decaying as much but they are decaying and so Chris looked at those as well and quoted that, said if we do them both at the same time, we’ll give a 5% discount. So, all in, he’s at $12,050 versus $9,500 and he’s doing a lot more work.

Rodgers said and those stone walls are our responsibility – Smith said correct – (continuing), Rodgers said just like that brick wall is.

Forte said remind me why they’re our responsibility. Smith said they’re in the city easement. You can see, it’s clearly those walls are on city property. Forte said thank you.

Wylie said were they constructed when the sewers all that? Smith said 2001, yes. Wylie said 2000, 2001? Smith said yes, approximately that time.

Wylie said anybody else, council members?

No comments.

Wylie said public?

Wylie said I’ve got Mr. Sims, is it? Yep. And then Bisio.

Sims said what would it cost to tear the wall out? Why are we paying to maintain a wall? We’re gonna maintain it again some other time. It just seems surprising that the village owns a wall. Smith said well, it’s – Sims said there, and it’s only, the only value of that wall is to the property owner. There’s no value of that wall to the village. Smith said if the property erodes onto the roadway, it is a safety concern. Sims said but isn’t that the homeowner’s responsibility? Smith said no, it’s in the city easement, it would be our responsibility. So, it’s, if you eliminated the walls and just tore them down, then the ground would slope and it would probably be a continual erosion problem. Look, the MDOT [Michigan Department of Transportation] engineers and city engineers back in 2001, whoever that was, looked at this and felt that there should be a retaining wall there, not just, because they could have at that time, just left it just to be a slope. Sims said sloped it over and grassed it. Smith said put grass on it. Maybe it would have held, maybe not. But they made that decision, and at this point I’m hoping to maintain that decision that was made back then.

Rodgers said so, does the easement start where these poles are? Is that like kind of the – Smith said the light pole you see in that picture is in the city easement.

Wylie recognized Bisio for a comment.

Bisio said yeah, I just had a question about the amounts. The two quotes you have are for $6,285 and $6,400. If you add those together, it’s $12,685. Smith said that’s 5% discount that he’s giving me. You can do both jobs at the same time. Bisio said OK, that explains it.

Wylie said anybody else, questions or comments?

Sims said so, the wall, I think there’s the apartments closer to, to town, which appears to look to be the same. Is that also owned by the village? Smith said that actually is in the property owner’s property. It cuts back a little bit, and it’s in their property. This wall, however, is ours. Sims said but their wall, because if I remember right, those two walls match. Smith said when the truck drove through that, they rebuilt their wall completely. What was that, 2019, something like that, when the truck drove through that and into the dentist’s office. And so, the owner of that apartment building, we appreciate, rebuilt that at their expense. They said, it’s our wall, it’s our responsibility. So, they did. So, it’s in better shape, because it was rebuilt not that long ago.

Wylie said you’re making the comment that they match? Sims said yeah, they match. So, I thought they were, because I was curious if they matched, thinking, OK, did someone own both these properties? To me, that would be the reason they would. I didn’t understand why they would match. (To Bisio), you weren’t in council in 2000, 2001, were you? I mean, I don’t know, anybody around anymore who knows what happened 25, 26 years ago.

Wylie said anybody else?

No comments.

Wylie said OK, we’ve got a resolve by Jones, supported by Sue Wylie. We need a roll call, Guillen, please.

Rodgers, Wylie, Jones, and Forte voted yes.

Wylie said OK, so the resolution is adopted, thank you.

Item #11d – Resolution: Exemptions to the Building Permitting Process (video time mark 1:13:19):

    • Resolution – Exemptions to the Building Permitting Process (page 36/39 of the council packet)
    • Construction Codes (page 37/39 of the council packet)

Wylie said and we have Item #11d, resolution exemptions to the building permitting process. I will read this.

(Wylie read the resolution.)

Wylie said and we’ll need somebody to resolve and then support.

Resolution by Jones; second Rodgers.

Wylie said any comments or questions from council members?

No comments.

Wylie said from the public.

Wylie recognized Bisio for a comment.

Bisio said I looked at this list of codes from the township and compared it with what’s in the city’s ordinances. The city’s ordinances haven’t been updated. We have obsolete BOCA [Building Officials and Code Administrators] code and other 1996 codes. So apparently what we have is the township enforcing its ordinances against city properties. And someone should look closely at the current city ordinances and conform them to whatever Independence Township is using so that there’s no confusion about what code applies. And if you issue tickets, the township inspector issues the tickets, somebody might raise that and say, you know, it doesn’t apply to me because it’s not in the city ordinance. Wylie said good point, thank you.

Smith said that’s not my understanding, however, and I’ll have to work with Gerry [Fisher. City attorney] and Kolb to find out. My understanding was that we continually adopt whatever the latest State of Michigan code is. Independence Township will tell you they do the same. They have just copied and pasted the state code into their website. And I was told that’s what we do, is we just continually adopt whatever is the latest code. Now, what is out on our website, I guess I need to check that to make sure it’s not referencing some 1996 code. The state is behind, you’ll see they’re still on 2015. Residential, 2022, it varies. But they’re in various states of approval all the time.

Bisio said so, if you’re saying that the code of ordinances that’s posted on the city’s website is not accurate, and there’s some other adoption by reference of some other codes, that should be clarified on the website. If there’s been an amendment to the code of ordinances, that should be available on the website so that people aren’t looking at what’s posted by the city and being confused as to what really applies. Wylie said yes, thank you.

Wylie recognized Sims for a comment.

Sims said yeah, so I’m assuming you passed this. When does it go into effect? Because right now I have shingles on my garage door. Wylie said I just got mine done last week. Sims said my roofer didn’t know. He said he was gonna contact me. But what you’re saying is my roof doesn’t need a permit. Smith said today, you don’t. But the only way you did in the city is require a roof permit is if you were replacing the sheathing underneath the shingles. That now becomes the structure of the building. It’s potentially load-bearing issues and whatnot. So that becomes an issue if you’re replacing sheathing. But if you’re just replacing shingles or overlaying, maybe you’re not even replacing it, you’re overlaying, then no, you don’t need a permit for that today. If we make this change, I don’t know how quickly it would take effect, but if you already have your work started, we’re not gonna hold you back. Sims said well, they haven’t started it. Well, they have the shingles on the roof. (unintelligible). Wylie said OK.

Wylie said anybody else?

Rodgers said what, Independence Township does require a permit when they reshingle their roofs? Smith said yes, whether sheathing is needed or not. They require a permit. Rodgers said and there is no, we don’t get any more money if they have to pull a permit. Smith said no. Rodgers said what is it designed for? Is there been issues with roofs that? Smith said well, we are not consistent with the township. And this question often comes up in what I have found in working with the township. Believe me, I have total respect for Dave Moran [Independence Township building official] and his crew and Kate. They’re very thorough. But what I have found in looking at some of the permits is some, there are some permits for roofing and flat work, and there’s others that were not permitted. So, I’d like to be consistent with the township. There’s no ambiguity. Like if there’s a roof replacement or a flat work, whether it’s in the city or in the township, it’s always, always permitted.

Rodgers said and when you permit somebody for that, are you, whoever does the permitting, are they checking to make sure it’s a reputable company? Like what is the permit for? Smith said it’s to come out and review the work to make sure it’s being done to current codes. So, they come out and will look at the job. I said in this motion, I put in there the fact that I was told back in the day, it was not uncommon for a municipality to exempt certain things from building code because you just didn’t have the inspectors to go out and do that, eyes on the ground and look. So, they just simplified their own process and flat work really, what could go wrong? But it’s not necessarily a good assumption. If they’re, they’re pouring a driveway that’s only two inches thick, it’s gonna crack and look bad. So, I think having somebody come out and look at the forms before the concrete’s poured is a good thing.

Wylie recognized Sims for a comment.

Sims said just a quick one. I had my, my basement, had a French drain put inside my basement. The inspector came out three different times, each phase along the way. Once they tore it out, they put the drain in, before they poured the concrete, after they poured it. So, they were out three times.

Wylie said anybody else?

No comments.

Wylie said Guillen, would you do the roll call for this please?

Jones, Forte, Rodgers, and Wylie voted yes.

Wylie said and the resolution is adopted.

Agenda Item #12, Adjourn Meeting (video time mark 1:21:12):

Wylie said and we are on Item #12. I need a motion to adjourn. Unless there’s anything else.

Did you have something else, Guillen?

Guillen said I just want clarification from Kolb. If the four council members, three voted yes and one voted no – Kolb said it fails. Guillen said if it fails, then they all have to (unintelligible). Kolb said we needed four votes to pass. Jones said the four on the (unintelligible). Guillen said OK. Kolb said yep.

Wylie said anybody else before we adjourn? I’m sorry, I need a motion to adjourn.

Motion by Jones. Wylie said because Jones gets to say what she wants tonight. She’s got a motion on it for every week. Jones said I keep hearing all the things that I’m supposed to hear. Wylie said I know, you want to go fast. Second Forte.

Motion to adjourn passed by unanimous voice vote.

Wylie said the meeting is adjourned at 8:21. Thank you very much, everybody.

Resources:

>